| DOB | Players | Clubs | Nationality | SD | A(D) | More |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 07-Aug-1987 |  Shaun Whalley | Accrington Stanley | England | 05-Aug-2023 | 35(363) | |
| 29-Nov-1987 |  David McGoldrick | Notts County | Republic of Ireland | 05-Aug-2023 | 35(249) | |
| 19-May-1989 | Jack Muldoon | Harrogate Town | England | 05-Aug-2023 | 34(77) | |
| 07-Jun-1989 | Matt Smith | Salford City | England | 05-Aug-2023 | 34(58) | |
| 12-Mar-1990 |  Mickey Demetriou | Crewe Alexandra | England | 05-Aug-2023 | 33(145) | |
| 11-Apr-1991 | Niall Canavan | Barrow | Republic of Ireland | 05-Aug-2023 | 32(115) | |
| 29-Oct-1991 |  Connor Jennings | Tranmere Rovers | England | 20-Oct-2023 | 31(355) | |
| 01-Apr-1992 | Harry Beautyman | Sutton United | England | 05-Aug-2023 | 31(125) | |
| 12-Aug-1992 | Conor McAleny | Salford City | England | 05-Aug-2023 | 30(358) | |
| 28-Feb-1993 |  Danny Johnson | Walsall | England | 05-Aug-2023 | 30(159) | |
| 25-Jun-1993 |  Jamie Walker | Bradford City | Scotland | 16-Sep-2023 | 30(82) | |
| 24-Jun-1993 | Joe Kizzi | Sutton United | England | 05-Aug-2023 | 30(41) | |
| 10-Dec-1993 | Danny Rose | Grimsby Town | England | 09-Sep-2023 | 29(272) | |
| 16-Nov-1993 | Anthony Forde | Wrexham | Republic of Ireland | 05-Aug-2023 | 29(262) | |
| 12-Jul-1994 |  Mohamed Eisa | Milton Keynes Dons | England | 05-Aug-2023 | 29(23) | |
| 18-May-1995 | Harry Smith | Sutton United | England | 05-Aug-2023 | 28(78) | |
| 15-Mar-1996 |  Harrison Biggins | Doncaster Rovers | England | 20-Oct-2023 | 27(217) | |
| 11-Feb-1996 | Alex Gilliead | Bradford City | England | 09-Sep-2023 | 27(211) | |
| 25-Apr-1996 | Bryn Morris | Newport County | England | 20-Oct-2023 | 27(176) | |
| 24-May-1996 | Omari Patrick | Sutton United | England | 05-Aug-2023 | 27(72) | |
| 11-Jul-1996 | Farrend Rawson | Morecambe | England | 05-Aug-2023 | 27(24) | |
| 27-Dec-1996 | Jacob Mendy | Wrexham | The Gambia | 05-Aug-2023 | 26(221) | |
| 01-Jul-1997 | Will Evans | Newport County | Wales | 20-Oct-2023 | 26(109) | |
| 12-Jun-1997 |  Will Wright | Crawley Town | England | 05-Aug-2023 | 26(53) | |
| 06-Sep-1997 | Alex Pattison | Bradford City | England | 15-Aug-2023 | 25(343) | |
| 02-Nov-1997 | Davis Keillor-Dunn | Mansfield Town | England | 05-Aug-2023 | 25(276) | |
| 14-Jul-1998 | Daniel Harvie | Milton Keynes Dons | Scotland | 05-Aug-2023 | 25(21) | |
| 18-Aug-1998 | Jordan Davies | Wrexham | Wales | 05-Aug-2023 | 24(352) | |
| 25-Sep-1998 |  Robbie McKenzie | Gillingham | England | 05-Aug-2023 | 24(314) | |
| 28-Jan-1999 | Josh Hawkes | Tranmere Rovers | England | 05-Aug-2023 | 24(190) |
SD = Scored Date ,
DOB = Date Of Birth ,
A(D) = Age(Days) .