| MD | Players | Clubs | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20-Oct-2023 |  Joe Murphy | Tranmere Rovers | Republic of Ireland | 21-Aug-1981 | 42(60) |
| 19-Aug-2023 |  Ben Foster | Wrexham | England | 03-Apr-1983 | 40(138) |
| 23-Sep-2023 |  Dean Lewington | Milton Keynes Dons | England | 18-May-1984 | 39(128) |
| 02-Sep-2023 |  Richard Wood | Doncaster Rovers | England | 05-Jul-1985 | 38(59) |
| 09-Sep-2023 |  Matt Derbyshire | Bradford City | England | 14-Apr-1986 | 37(148) |
| 26-Aug-2023 | Stephen Quinn | Mansfield Town | Republic of Ireland | 01-Apr-1986 | 37(147) |
| 28-Oct-2023 | Adrian Mariappa | Salford City | Jamaica | 03-Oct-1986 | 37(25) |
| 31-Oct-2023 | Sam Foley | Barrow | Republic of Ireland | 17-Oct-1986 | 37(14) |
| 23-Sep-2023 | Mark Howard | Wrexham | England | 21-Sep-1986 | 37(2) |
| 14-Oct-2023 |  Shaun Williams | Gillingham | Republic of Ireland | 19-Oct-1986 | 36(360) |
| 28-Oct-2023 | Robert Milsom | Sutton United | England | 02-Jan-1987 | 36(299) |
| 21-Oct-2023 | Steven Fletcher | Wrexham | Scotland | 26-Mar-1987 | 36(209) |
| 11-Nov-2023 | Shaun Whalley | Accrington Stanley | England | 07-Aug-1987 | 36(96) |
| 19-Aug-2023 | Josh Lillis | Barrow | England | 24-Jun-1987 | 36(56) |
| 18-Nov-2023 |  Jim O'Brien | Notts County | Republic of Ireland | 28-Sep-1987 | 36(51) |
| 18-Nov-2023 | David McGoldrick | Notts County | Republic of Ireland | 29-Nov-1987 | 35(355) |
| 23-Sep-2023 | Luke Daniels | Forest Green Rovers | England | 05-Jan-1988 | 35(262) |
| 18-Nov-2023 | Sam Slocombe | Notts County | England | 05-Jun-1988 | 35(166) |
| 11-Nov-2023 | Troy Deeney | Forest Green Rovers | England | 29-Jun-1988 | 35(135) |
| 18-Nov-2023 | Seamus Conneely | Accrington Stanley | Republic of Ireland | 09-Jul-1988 | 35(132) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).