| MD | Players | Clubs | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 02-Nov-2011 |  Kasey Keller | Seattle Sounders | United States | 19-Nov-1969 | 41(348) |
| 03-Nov-2011 | Faryd Mondragon | Philadelphia Union | Colombia | 21-Jun-1971 | 40(135) |
| 03-Nov-2011 | Frank Rost | New York Red Bulls | Germany | 30-Jun-1973 | 38(126) |
| 26-Oct-2011 | Kevin Hartman | FC Dallas | United States | 24-May-1974 | 37(155) |
| 30-Oct-2011 | Tyrone Marshall | Colorado Rapids | Jamaica | 12-Nov-1974 | 36(352) |
| 20-Nov-2011 | David Beckham | Los Angeles Galaxy | England | 02-May-1975 | 36(202) |
| 26-Oct-2011 | Daniel Hernandez | FC Dallas | United States | 23-Jul-1976 | 35(95) |
| 27-Oct-2011 | Jeff Cunningham | Columbus Crew | United States | 21-Aug-1976 | 35(67) |
| 06-Nov-2011 | Jimmy Nielsen | Sporting Kansas City | Denmark | 06-Aug-1977 | 34(92) |
| 03-Nov-2011 | Thierry Henry | New York Red Bulls | France | 17-Aug-1977 | 34(78) |
| 03-Nov-2011 | Veljko Paunovic | Philadelphia Union | Serbia and Montenegro | 21-Aug-1977 | 34(74) |
| 06-Nov-2011 | Andy Williams | Real Salt Lake | Jamaica | 23-Sep-1977 | 34(44) |
| 30-Oct-2011 | Stefani Miglioranzi | Philadelphia Union | Brazil | 20-Sep-1977 | 34(40) |
| 02-Nov-2011 | Brian Mullan | Colorado Rapids | United States | 23-Apr-1978 | 33(193) |
| 27-Oct-2011 | Andres Mendoza | Columbus Crew | Peru | 26-Apr-1978 | 33(184) |
| 20-Nov-2011 | Brian Ching | Houston Dynamo | United States | 24-May-1978 | 33(180) |
| 06-Nov-2011 | Julio Cesar | Sporting Kansas City | Brazil | 18-Nov-1978 | 32(353) |
| 26-Oct-2011 | Jair Benitez | FC Dallas | Colombia | 12-Jan-1979 | 32(287) |
| 02-Nov-2011 | Birahim Diop | Sporting Kansas City | Senegal | 07-Feb-1979 | 32(268) |
| 30-Oct-2011 | Rafael Marquez (Mex) | New York Red Bulls | Mexico | 13-Feb-1979 | 32(259) |
| 06-Nov-2011 | Nick Rimando | Real Salt Lake | United States | 17-Jun-1979 | 32(142) |
| 06-Nov-2011 | Robbie Russell | Real Salt Lake | United States | 16-Jul-1979 | 32(113) |
| 26-Oct-2011 | Ricardo Villar | FC Dallas | Brazil | 11-Aug-1979 | 32(76) |
| 03-Nov-2011 | Teemu Tainio | New York Red Bulls | Finland | 27-Nov-1979 | 31(342) |
| 06-Nov-2011 | Javier Morales | Real Salt Lake | Argentina | 10-Jan-1980 | 31(300) |
| 06-Nov-2011 | Omar Bravo | Sporting Kansas City | Mexico | 04-Mar-1980 | 31(247) |
| 03-Nov-2011 | Danny Califf | Philadelphia Union | United States | 17-Mar-1980 | 31(231) |
| 06-Nov-2011 | Davy Arnaud | Sporting Kansas City | United States | 22-Jun-1980 | 31(136) |
| 20-Nov-2011 | Robbie Keane | Los Angeles Galaxy | Republic of Ireland | 08-Jul-1980 | 31(134) |
| 27-Oct-2011 | Sebastian Miranda | Columbus Crew | Chile | 26-Jun-1980 | 31(123) |
| 02-Nov-2011 | Zach Scott | Seattle Sounders | United States | 02-Jul-1980 | 31(123) |
| 02-Nov-2011 | Leonardo Gonzalez | Seattle Sounders | Costa Rica | 21-Nov-1980 | 30(346) |
| 27-Oct-2011 | Jamie Smith | Colorado Rapids | Scotland | 20-Nov-1980 | 30(341) |
| 20-Nov-2011 | Todd Dunivant | Los Angeles Galaxy | United States | 26-Dec-1980 | 30(329) |
| 30-Oct-2011 | Carlos Mendes | New York Red Bulls | United States | 25-Dec-1980 | 30(309) |
| 02-Nov-2011 | Roger Levesque | Seattle Sounders | United States | 22-Jan-1981 | 30(284) |
| 20-Nov-2011 | Josh Saunders | Los Angeles Galaxy | United States | 02-Mar-1981 | 30(263) |
| 29-Oct-2011 | Nat Borchers | Real Salt Lake | United States | 13-Apr-1981 | 30(199) |
| 06-Nov-2011 | Jamison Olave | Real Salt Lake | Colombia | 21-Apr-1981 | 30(199) |
| 03-Nov-2011 | Jan Gunnar Solli | New York Red Bulls | Norway | 19-Apr-1981 | 30(198) |
| 26-Oct-2011 | Daniel Cruz | FC Dallas | Colombia | 03-May-1981 | 30(176) |
| 03-Nov-2011 | Brian Carroll | Philadelphia Union | United States | 20-Jul-1981 | 30(106) |
| 03-Nov-2011 | Joel Lindpere | New York Red Bulls | Estonia | 05-Oct-1981 | 30(29) |
| 06-Nov-2011 | Brad Davis | Houston Dynamo | United States | 08-Nov-1981 | 29(363) |
| 27-Oct-2011 | Will Hesmer | Columbus Crew | United States | 23-Nov-1981 | 29(338) |
| 03-Nov-2011 | Luke Rodgers | New York Red Bulls | England | 01-Jan-1982 | 29(306) |
| 20-Nov-2011 | Landon Donovan | Los Angeles Galaxy | United States | 04-Mar-1982 | 29(261) |
| 02-Nov-2011 | Miguel Comminges | Colorado Rapids | Guadeloupe | 16-Mar-1982 | 29(231) |
| 06-Nov-2011 | Alvaro Saborio | Real Salt Lake | Costa Rica | 25-Mar-1982 | 29(226) |
| 02-Nov-2011 | Jeff Parke | Seattle Sounders | United States | 23-Mar-1982 | 29(224) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).