| MD | Players | Clubs | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23-May-2009 |  Simon Royce | Gillingham | England | 09-Sep-1971 | 37(257) |
| 10-May-2009 | Nicky Southall | Gillingham | England | 28-Jan-1972 | 37(103) |
| 10-May-2009 |  Efetobore Sodje | Bury | Nigeria | 05-Feb-1972 | 37(95) |
| 10-May-2009 | Andy Morrell | Bury | England | 28-Sep-1974 | 34(225) |
| 23-May-2009 |  Graham Coughlan | Shrewsbury Town | Republic of Ireland | 18-Nov-1974 | 34(187) |
| 10-May-2009 |  Lee Thorpe | Rochdale | England | 14-Dec-1975 | 33(148) |
| 10-May-2009 | Glynn Hurst | Bury | South Africa | 17-Jan-1976 | 33(114) |
| 23-May-2009 | Paul Murray | Shrewsbury Town | England | 31-Aug-1976 | 32(265) |
| 10-May-2009 | Wayne Brown | Bury | England | 14-Jan-1977 | 32(116) |
| 10-May-2009 | Gary Jones | Rochdale | England | 03-Jun-1977 | 31(342) |
| 23-May-2009 | Kevin McIntyre | Shrewsbury Town | England | 23-Dec-1977 | 31(152) |
| 10-May-2009 | Mark Bentley | Gillingham | England | 07-Jan-1978 | 31(123) |
| 10-May-2009 | Brian Barry-Murphy | Bury | Republic of Ireland | 27-Jul-1978 | 30(288) |
| 10-May-2009 | Mark McCammon | Gillingham | Barbados | 07-Aug-1978 | 30(277) |
| 10-May-2009 | Phillip Jevons | Bury | England | 01-Aug-1979 | 29(283) |
| 10-May-2009 | Steve Haslam | Bury | England | 06-Sep-1979 | 29(247) |
| 23-May-2009 | Omer Riza | Shrewsbury Town | Turkey | 08-Nov-1979 | 29(197) |
| 23-May-2009 | Grant Holt | Shrewsbury Town | England | 12-Apr-1981 | 28(41) |
| 10-May-2009 | Nathan Stanton | Rochdale | England | 06-May-1981 | 28(4) |
| 23-May-2009 | Darren Moss | Shrewsbury Town | Wales | 24-May-1981 | 27(364) |
| 23-May-2009 | Ben Davies | Shrewsbury Town | England | 27-May-1981 | 27(361) |
| 10-May-2009 | Ben Futcher | Bury | England | 04-Jun-1981 | 27(340) |
| 10-May-2009 | Ciaran Toner | Rochdale | Northern Ireland | 30-Jun-1981 | 27(314) |
| 10-May-2009 | Simon Ramsden | Rochdale | England | 17-Dec-1981 | 27(144) |
| 23-May-2009 | John Nutter | Gillingham | England | 13-Jun-1982 | 26(345) |
| 23-May-2009 | Nick Chadwick | Shrewsbury Town | England | 26-Oct-1982 | 26(210) |
| 10-May-2009 | Andy Bishop | Bury | England | 19-Oct-1982 | 26(204) |
| 23-May-2009 | Simon King | Gillingham | England | 11-Apr-1983 | 26(43) |
| 10-May-2009 | Jon Shaw | Rochdale | England | 14-Nov-1983 | 25(178) |
| 07-May-2009 | John Welsh | Bury | England | 10-Jan-1984 | 25(118) |
| 23-May-2009 | Dennis Oli | Gillingham | England | 28-Jan-1984 | 25(116) |
| 10-May-2009 | Adam Rundle | Rochdale | England | 08-Jul-1984 | 24(306) |
| 23-May-2009 | Barry Fuller | Gillingham | England | 25-Sep-1984 | 24(240) |
| 07-May-2009 | Albert Jarrett | Gillingham | Sierra Leone | 23-Oct-1984 | 24(196) |
| 23-May-2009 | Kelvin Langmead | Shrewsbury Town | England | 23-Mar-1985 | 24(61) |
| 23-May-2009 | Neil Ashton | Shrewsbury Town | England | 15-Apr-1985 | 24(38) |
| 10-May-2009 | Tom Kennedy | Rochdale | England | 24-Jun-1985 | 23(320) |
| 10-May-2009 | Stephen Dawson | Bury | Republic of Ireland | 04-Dec-1985 | 23(157) |
| 10-May-2009 | Chris Dagnall | Rochdale | England | 15-Apr-1986 | 23(25) |
| 10-May-2009 | David Buchanan | Bury | Northern Ireland | 06-May-1986 | 23(4) |
| 23-May-2009 | Garry Richards | Gillingham | England | 11-Jun-1986 | 22(347) |
| 10-May-2009 | Adam Le Fondre | Rochdale | England | 02-Dec-1986 | 22(160) |
| 23-May-2009 | Andy Barcham | Gillingham | England | 16-Dec-1986 | 22(159) |
| 23-May-2009 | Curtis Weston | Gillingham | England | 24-Jan-1987 | 22(120) |
| 23-May-2009 | Simeon Jackson | Gillingham | Canada | 28-Mar-1987 | 22(57) |
| 10-May-2009 | Rory McArdle | Rochdale | Northern Ireland | 01-May-1987 | 22(10) |
| 23-May-2009 | Moses Ashikodi | Shrewsbury Town | Antigua and Barbuda | 27-Jun-1987 | 21(331) |
| 10-May-2009 | Mike Jones | Bury | England | 15-Aug-1987 | 21(269) |
| 23-May-2009 | Chris Humphrey | Shrewsbury Town | Jamaica | 19-Sep-1987 | 21(247) |
| 23-May-2009 | Stuart Lewis | Gillingham | England | 15-Oct-1987 | 21(221) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).