| MD | Players | Clubs | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10-Nov-2008 |  Michael Haswell | AFC Wimbledon | England | 03-May-1962 | 46(192) |
| 09-Nov-2008 | John Purdie | Hornchurch | England | 22-Feb-1967 | 41(261) |
| 18-Nov-2008 |  Mark Crossley | Oldham Athletic | Wales | 16-Jun-1969 | 39(156) |
| 29-Nov-2008 |  Tony Roberts | Dagenham & Redbridge | Wales | 04-Aug-1969 | 39(118) |
| 29-Nov-2008 |  Chris Powell | Leicester City | England | 08-Sep-1969 | 39(83) |
| 04-Feb-2009 |  Neil Sullivan | Doncaster Rovers | Scotland | 24-Feb-1970 | 38(346) |
| 24-Feb-2009 |  Kerimoglu Tugay | Blackburn Rovers | Turkey | 24-Aug-1970 | 38(185) |
| 24-Jan-2009 |  David James | Portsmouth | England | 01-Aug-1970 | 38(177) |
| 07-Mar-2009 |  Edwin van der Sar | Manchester United | Netherlands | 29-Oct-1970 | 38(130) |
| 03-Jan-2009 | Jeremy Gill | Forest Green Rovers | England | 08-Sep-1970 | 38(118) |
| 29-Nov-2008 | Ricky Newman | Aldershot Town | England | 05-Aug-1970 | 38(117) |
| 29-Nov-2008 | Fabian Wilnis | Grays Athletic | Netherlands | 23-Aug-1970 | 38(99) |
| 08-Nov-2008 | Gavin Johnson | Bury Town | England | 10-Oct-1970 | 38(30) |
| 15-Feb-2009 |  Brad Friedel | Aston Villa | United States | 18-May-1971 | 37(274) |
| 29-Nov-2008 | Martin McIntosh | Alfreton Town | Scotland | 19-Mar-1971 | 37(256) |
| 08-Nov-2008 | Leo Fortune-West | Alfreton Town | England | 09-Apr-1971 | 37(214) |
| 08-Nov-2008 | Jason Lee | Mansfield Town | England | 09-May-1971 | 37(184) |
| 08-Mar-2009 |  Graham Alexander | Burnley | Scotland | 10-Oct-1971 | 37(150) |
| 13-Jan-2009 |  Maik Taylor | Birmingham City | Northern Ireland | 04-Sep-1971 | 37(132) |
| 04-Jan-2009 |  Simon Royce | Gillingham | England | 09-Sep-1971 | 37(118) |
| 13-Jan-2009 |  Alan Wright | Cheltenham Town | England | 28-Sep-1971 | 37(108) |
| 24-Jan-2009 |  Ian Bennett | Sheffield United | England | 10-Oct-1971 | 37(107) |
| 04-Feb-2009 |  Dwight Yorke | Sunderland | Trinidad and Tobago | 03-Nov-1971 | 37(94) |
| 24-Jan-2009 | Lee Harper | Kettering Town | England | 30-Oct-1971 | 37(87) |
| 08-Nov-2008 | Martin Gray | Darlington | England | 17-Aug-1971 | 37(84) |
| 18-Nov-2008 | Lee Harrison | Barnet | England | 12-Sep-1971 | 37(68) |
| 17-Nov-2008 |  Paul Telfer | Leeds United | Scotland | 21-Oct-1971 | 37(28) |
| 09-Nov-2008 | Michael Bell | Team Bath | England | 15-Nov-1971 | 36(360) |
| 08-Nov-2008 |  Kevin Gray | Chesterfield | England | 07-Jan-1972 | 36(306) |
| 08-Nov-2008 |  Efetobore Sodje | Bury | Nigeria | 05-Feb-1972 | 36(277) |
| 29-Nov-2008 |  Darren Anderton | AFC Bournemouth | England | 03-Mar-1972 | 36(271) |
| 24-Jan-2009 | Chris Hargreaves | Torquay United | England | 12-May-1972 | 36(257) |
| 02-Dec-2008 | Barry Hayles | Cheltenham Town | Jamaica | 17-Apr-1972 | 36(229) |
| 07-Mar-2009 |  Mark Schwarzer | Fulham | Australia | 06-Oct-1972 | 36(152) |
| 09-Dec-2008 |  Ian Goodison | Tranmere Rovers | Jamaica | 05-Aug-1972 | 36(126) |
| 08-Nov-2008 |  Clayton Ince | Walsall | Trinidad and Tobago | 13-Jul-1972 | 36(118) |
| 14-Jan-2009 | Paul Dickov | Leicester City | Scotland | 01-Nov-1972 | 36(74) |
| 29-Nov-2008 | Tony Butler | Alfreton Town | England | 28-Sep-1972 | 36(62) |
| 24-Jan-2009 | Nicky Eaden | Kettering Town | England | 12-Dec-1972 | 36(43) |
| 14-Jan-2009 | Marc Edworthy | Leicester City | England | 24-Dec-1972 | 36(21) |
| 10-Dec-2008 |  Russell Hoult | Notts County | England | 22-Nov-1972 | 36(18) |
| 18-Nov-2008 | Colin Little | Altrincham | England | 04-Nov-1972 | 36(14) |
| 08-Nov-2008 | Steve West | Sutton United | England | 05-Nov-1972 | 36(3) |
| 08-Nov-2008 |  Marcus Stewart | Exeter City | England | 07-Nov-1972 | 36(1) |
| 02-Dec-2008 | Drissa Diallo | Cheltenham Town | Guinea | 04-Jan-1973 | 35(333) |
| 03-Jan-2009 | Kevin Austin | Chesterfield | Trinidad and Tobago | 12-Feb-1973 | 35(326) |
| 13-Jan-2009 | Gareth Taylor | Doncaster Rovers | Wales | 25-Feb-1973 | 35(323) |
| 13-Jan-2009 | Alex Russell | Cheltenham Town | England | 17-Mar-1973 | 35(303) |
| 09-Dec-2008 | Neil Sorvel | Droylesden | England | 02-Mar-1973 | 35(283) |
| 29-Nov-2008 | Tom Curtis | Alfreton Town | England | 01-Mar-1973 | 35(274) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).