| Yellow | Clubs | VS Club | Date | Sections | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | Everton | Sunderland | 27-03-2012 | Sixth Round Replay | Match details |
| 4 | Stoke City | Liverpool | 18-03-2012 | Sixth Round | Match details |
| 4 | Stoke City | Derby County | 28-01-2012 | Fourth Round | Match details |
| 4 | Bolton Wanderers | Swansea City | 28-01-2012 | Fourth Round | Match details |
| 4 | Wrexham | Brighton & Hove Albion | 18-01-2012 | Third Round Replays | Match details |
| 4 | Manchester United | Manchester City | 08-01-2012 | Third Round | Match details |
| 4 | Portsmouth | Chelsea | 08-01-2012 | Third Round | Match details |
| 4 | Yeovil Town | Fleetwood Town | 13-12-2011 | Second Round Replays | Match details |
| 4 | Barnet | Milton Keynes Dons | 03-12-2011 | Second Round | Match details |
| 4 | Southend United | Oldham Athletic | 03-12-2011 | Second Round | Match details |
