| DOB | Players | Clubs | Nationality | SD | A(D) | More |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 03-Nov-1971 |  Dwight Yorke | Trinidad and Tobago | Trinidad and Tobago | 11-Feb-2009 | 37(98) | |
| 17-Jan-1973 |  Cuauhtemoc Blanco | Mexico | Mexico | 10-Oct-2009 | 36(265) | |
| 28-Apr-1973 | Juan Francisco Palencia | Mexico | Mexico | 10-Oct-2009 | 36(163) | |
| 09-Oct-1973 |  Carlos Pavon | Honduras | Honduras | 14-Oct-2009 | 36(4) | |
| 06-Oct-1974 |  Walter Centeno | Costa Rica | Costa Rica | 10-Oct-2009 | 35(3) | |
| 05-Aug-1974 |  Frankie Hejduk | United States | United States | 28-Mar-2009 | 34(235) | |
| 02-May-1976 | Amado Guevara | Honduras | Honduras | 05-Sep-2009 | 33(124) | |
| 03-Nov-1976 | Guillermo Franco | Mexico | Mexico | 05-Sep-2009 | 32(305) | |
| 26-Jul-1976 | Pavel Pardo | Mexico | Mexico | 28-Mar-2009 | 32(244) | |
| 24-Oct-1978 | Carlos Edwards | Trinidad and Tobago | Trinidad and Tobago | 06-Jun-2009 | 30(225) | |
| 13-Sep-1979 | Julio Cesar Leon | Honduras | Honduras | 10-Oct-2009 | 30(26) | |
| 25-May-1979 | Carlos Bocanegra | United States | United States | 06-Jun-2009 | 30(11) | |
| 06-Nov-1979 | Rudis Corrales | El Salvador | El Salvador | 09-Sep-2009 | 29(306) | |
| 05-Nov-1979 | David Suazo | Honduras | Honduras | 05-Sep-2009 | 29(304) | |
| 14-Nov-1979 | Miguel Sabah | Mexico | Mexico | 12-Aug-2009 | 29(271) | |
| 02-Apr-1980 | Carlos Salcido | Mexico | Mexico | 14-Oct-2009 | 29(194) | |
| 03-Jan-1980 | Andy Furtado | Costa Rica | Costa Rica | 11-Feb-2009 | 29(37) | |
| 04-Mar-1980 | Omar Bravo | Mexico | Mexico | 28-Mar-2009 | 29(23) | |
| 21-Oct-1980 | Cornell Glen | Trinidad and Tobago | Trinidad and Tobago | 12-Aug-2009 | 28(295) | |
| 20-Dec-1980 | Israel Castro | Mexico | Mexico | 12-Aug-2009 | 28(235) | |
| 25-Jul-1981 | Conor Casey | United States | United States | 10-Oct-2009 | 28(75) | |
| 01-Dec-1981 | Kerry Baptiste | Trinidad and Tobago | Trinidad and Tobago | 14-Oct-2009 | 27(316) | |
| 21-Aug-1981 | Oscar Rojas | Mexico | Mexico | 10-Jun-2009 | 27(293) | |
| 27-Aug-1981 | Collin Samuel | Trinidad and Tobago | Trinidad and Tobago | 06-Jun-2009 | 27(283) | |
| 04-Mar-1982 | Landon Donovan | United States | United States | 10-Oct-2009 | 27(218) | |
| 25-Mar-1982 | Alvaro Saborio | Costa Rica | Costa Rica | 10-Oct-2009 | 27(197) | |
| 17-Jul-1982 | Carlo Costly | Honduras | Honduras | 12-Aug-2009 | 27(25) | |
| 10-Feb-1983 | Ricardo Clark | United States | United States | 09-Sep-2009 | 26(212) | |
| 09-Mar-1983 | Clint Dempsey | United States | United States | 05-Sep-2009 | 26(178) | |
| 05-Feb-1983 | Eliseo Quintanilla | El Salvador | El Salvador | 06-Jun-2009 | 26(122) |
SD = Scored Date ,
DOB = Date Of Birth ,
A(D) = Age(Days) .