| DOB | Players | Clubs | Nationality | SD | A(D) | More |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12-Feb-1959 |  Mick Harford | Milton Keynes Dons | England | 24-Feb-1996 | 37(11) | |
| 04-Dec-1959 |  Paul McGrath | Aston Villa | Republic of Ireland | 17-Apr-1996 | 36(134) | |
| 18-Jan-1961 |  Peter Beardsley | Newcastle United | England | 02-May-1996 | 35(104) | |
| 31-Dec-1960 |  Steve Bruce | Manchester United | England | 25-Feb-1996 | 35(54) | |
| 20-Oct-1961 |  Ian Rush | Liverpool | Wales | 05-May-1996 | 34(197) | |
| 07-Nov-1961 |  Mark Hateley | Queens Park Rangers | England | 08-Apr-1996 | 34(152) | |
| 20-Nov-1961 |  Dave Watson | Everton | England | 24-Feb-1996 | 34(94) | |
| 18-May-1962 | Barry Horne | Everton | Wales | 03-Feb-1996 | 33(258) | |
| 24-Apr-1962 |  Stuart Pearce | Nottingham Forest | England | 30-Dec-1995 | 33(248) | |
| 17-Mar-1962 |  Chris Waddle | Sheffield Wednesday | England | 21-Nov-1995 | 33(246) | |
| 01-Sep-1962 |  Ruud Gullit | Chelsea | Netherlands | 12-Mar-1996 | 33(193) | |
| 06-Jun-1962 | Mark Bright | Sheffield Wednesday | England | 16-Dec-1995 | 33(192) | |
| 12-Mar-1963 | Ian Holloway | Queens Park Rangers | England | 06-Apr-1996 | 33(24) | |
| 01-Aug-1963 | Mark Wright | Liverpool | England | 16-Mar-1996 | 32(227) | |
| 23-Jul-1963 | Andy Townsend | Aston Villa | Republic of Ireland | 06-Mar-1996 | 32(224) | |
| 09-May-1963 |  Richard Jobson | Leeds United | England | 09-Dec-1995 | 32(212) | |
| 01-Nov-1963 | Mark Hughes | Chelsea | Wales | 27-Apr-1996 | 32(177) | |
| 03-Nov-1963 |  Ian Wright | Arsenal | England | 27-Apr-1996 | 32(175) | |
| 07-Nov-1963 | John Barnes | Liverpool | England | 08-Apr-1996 | 32(152) | |
| 11-Dec-1963 | Nigel Winterburn | Arsenal | England | 16-Mar-1996 | 32(95) | |
| 24-Oct-1963 |  John Hendrie | Middlesbrough | Scotland | 23-Dec-1995 | 32(58) | |
| 12-Oct-1963 | Alan McDonald | Queens Park Rangers | Northern Ireland | 02-Dec-1995 | 32(49) | |
| 08-Apr-1964 |  John McGinlay | Bolton Wanderers | Scotland | 08-Apr-1996 | 31(365) | |
| 24-Dec-1963 | Chris Morris | Middlesbrough | Republic of Ireland | 23-Dec-1995 | 31(363) | |
| 17-Mar-1964 | Lee Dixon | Arsenal | England | 05-Mar-1996 | 31(351) | |
| 08-Dec-1963 | Brian McClair | Manchester United | Scotland | 22-Nov-1995 | 31(348) | |
| 18-Oct-1963 |  Marques Isaias | Coventry City | Brazil | 16-Sep-1995 | 31(332) | |
| 04-Oct-1963 |  Ronny Rosenthal | Tottenham Hotspur | Israel | 30-Aug-1995 | 31(329) | |
| 04-Nov-1964 | Simon Barker | Queens Park Rangers | England | 23-Mar-1996 | 31(140) | |
| 29-Nov-1964 |  Ken Monkou | Southampton | Netherlands | 13-Apr-1996 | 31(136) |
SD = Scored Date ,
DOB = Date Of Birth ,
A(D) = Age(Days) .