| MD | Players | Clubs | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 06-Jan-2024 |  Curtis Davies | Cheltenham Town | England | 15-Mar-1985 | 38(297) |
| 29-Dec-2023 |  Darren Pratley | Leyton Orient | England | 22-Apr-1985 | 38(251) |
| 26-Dec-2023 |  Richard Keogh | Wycombe Wanderers | Republic of Ireland | 11-Aug-1986 | 37(137) |
| 26-Dec-2023 | Joe Jacobson | Wycombe Wanderers | Wales | 17-Nov-1986 | 37(39) |
| 24-Oct-2023 |  Cameron Jerome | Bolton Wanderers | England | 14-Oct-1986 | 37(10) |
| 06-Jan-2024 | Garath McCleary | Wycombe Wanderers | Jamaica | 15-May-1987 | 36(236) |
| 11-Nov-2023 |  Paul Huntington | Carlisle United | England | 17-Sep-1987 | 36(55) |
| 25-Nov-2023 |  George Friend | Bristol Rovers | England | 19-Oct-1987 | 36(37) |
| 06-Jan-2024 |  John Brayford | Burton Albion | England | 29-Dec-1987 | 36(8) |
| 26-Dec-2023 | Michael Morrison | Cambridge United | England | 03-Mar-1988 | 35(298) |
| 01-Jan-2024 | Joe Garner | Carlisle United | England | 12-Apr-1988 | 35(264) |
| 23-Dec-2023 | Mustapha Carayol | Burton Albion | The Gambia | 04-Sep-1988 | 35(110) |
| 01-Jan-2024 | Chris Martin | Bristol Rovers | Scotland | 04-Nov-1988 | 35(58) |
| 01-Jan-2024 |  Elliott Bennett | Shrewsbury Town | England | 18-Dec-1988 | 35(14) |
| 06-Jan-2024 |  Craig Forsyth | Derby County | Scotland | 24-Feb-1989 | 34(316) |
| 01-Jan-2024 |  David Button | Reading | England | 27-Feb-1989 | 34(308) |
| 29-Dec-2023 | James Wilson | Bristol Rovers | Wales | 26-Feb-1989 | 34(306) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).