| MD | Players | Clubs | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 07-Jan-2012 |  David James | Bristol City | England | 01-Aug-1970 | 41(159) |
| 04-Dec-2011 |  Paul Telfer | Sutton United | Scotland | 21-Oct-1971 | 40(44) |
| 12-Nov-2011 | Ashley Bayes | Basingstoke Town | England | 19-Apr-1972 | 39(207) |
| 12-Nov-2011 | Chris MacKenzie | Corby Town | England | 14-May-1972 | 39(182) |
| 22-Nov-2011 |  Steve Fletcher | AFC Bournemouth | England | 26-Jun-1972 | 39(149) |
| 12-Nov-2011 |  Ian Goodison | Tranmere Rovers | Jamaica | 05-Aug-1972 | 39(99) |
| 12-Nov-2011 | Rodney Jack | Nantwich Town | Saint Vincent and the Grenadin | 28-Sep-1972 | 39(45) |
| 23-Nov-2011 | Alex Russell | Bath City | England | 17-Mar-1973 | 38(251) |
| 15-Apr-2012 |  Carlo Cudicini | Tottenham Hotspur | Italy | 06-Sep-1973 | 38(222) |
| 18-Feb-2012 |  Kevin Phillips | Blackpool | England | 25-Jul-1973 | 38(208) |
| 13-Dec-2011 |  Jimmy Walker | Walsall | England | 09-Jul-1973 | 38(157) |
| 29-Jan-2012 |  Danny Coyne | Middlesbrough | Wales | 27-Aug-1973 | 38(155) |
| 28-Jan-2012 |  Ryan Giggs | Manchester United | Wales | 29-Nov-1973 | 38(60) |
| 12-Nov-2011 |  Nick Colgan | Huddersfield Town | Republic of Ireland | 19-Sep-1973 | 38(54) |
| 22-Nov-2011 | Lee Steele | Oxford City | England | 07-Dec-1973 | 37(350) |
| 07-Jan-2012 |  Radek Cerny | Queens Park Rangers | Czech Republic | 18-Feb-1974 | 37(323) |
| 12-Nov-2011 |  Scott McGleish | Bristol Rovers | England | 10-Feb-1974 | 37(275) |
| 03-Dec-2011 |  Kevin Pilkington | Luton Town | England | 08-Mar-1974 | 37(270) |
| 07-Jan-2012 |  Matthew Lawrence | Gillingham | England | 19-Jun-1974 | 37(202) |
| 23-Nov-2011 | Scott Murray | Bath City | Scotland | 26-May-1974 | 37(181) |
| 18-Jan-2012 | Andy Morrell | Wrexham | England | 28-Sep-1974 | 37(112) |
| 28-Jan-2012 | Paul Scholes | Manchester United | England | 16-Nov-1974 | 37(73) |
| 12-Nov-2011 |  Nolberto Solano | Hartlepool United | Peru | 12-Dec-1974 | 36(335) |
| 12-Nov-2011 | Wayne Hatswell | Newport County | England | 08-Feb-1975 | 36(277) |
| 07-Mar-2012 |  Chris Day | Stevenage | England | 28-Jul-1975 | 36(223) |
| 17-Jan-2012 |  George Boateng | Nottingham Forest | Netherlands | 05-Sep-1975 | 36(134) |
| 03-Dec-2011 |  Jamie Cureton | Leyton Orient | England | 28-Aug-1975 | 36(97) |
| 07-Jan-2012 | Glen Little | Wrexham | England | 15-Oct-1975 | 36(84) |
| 12-Nov-2011 | Derek Brown | Arlesey Town | England | 08-Nov-1975 | 36(4) |
| 13-Nov-2011 | Stewart Drummond | Morecambe | England | 11-Dec-1975 | 35(338) |
| 29-Jan-2012 |  Shay Given | Aston Villa | Republic of Ireland | 20-Apr-1976 | 35(284) |
| 18-Mar-2012 |  Thomas Sorensen | Stoke City | Denmark | 12-Jun-1976 | 35(280) |
| 28-Jan-2012 |  Steven Howard | Leicester City | Scotland | 10-May-1976 | 35(263) |
| 18-Mar-2012 | Rory Delap | Stoke City | Republic of Ireland | 06-Jul-1976 | 35(256) |
| 28-Jan-2012 |  Lee Hughes | Notts County | England | 22-May-1976 | 35(251) |
| 23-Nov-2011 | Jim Rollo | Bath City | England | 25-May-1976 | 35(182) |
| 18-Feb-2012 |  Stephen Carr | Birmingham City | Republic of Ireland | 29-Aug-1976 | 35(173) |
| 12-Nov-2011 | Bryan Hughes | Accrington Stanley | England | 19-Jun-1976 | 35(146) |
| 14-Apr-2012 |  Phil Neville | Everton | England | 21-Jan-1977 | 35(84) |
| 12-Nov-2011 | Phil Bolland | Barrow | England | 26-Aug-1976 | 35(78) |
| 12-Nov-2011 |  Ashley Westwood | Northampton Town | England | 31-Aug-1976 | 35(73) |
| 12-Nov-2011 |  Romain Larrieu | Plymouth Argyle | France | 31-Aug-1976 | 35(73) |
| 12-Nov-2011 |  Ian Ashbee | Preston North End | England | 06-Sep-1976 | 35(67) |
| 06-Jan-2012 |  Shefki Kuqi | Oldham Athletic | Finland | 10-Nov-1976 | 35(57) |
| 13-Dec-2011 |  Kevin Maher | Dagenham & Redbridge | Republic of Ireland | 17-Oct-1976 | 35(57) |
| 07-Jan-2012 | Iyseden Christie | Tamworth | England | 14-Nov-1976 | 35(54) |
| 03-Dec-2011 | Jamie Stuart | AFC Wimbledon | England | 15-Oct-1976 | 35(49) |
| 13-Dec-2011 | Peter Gain | Dagenham & Redbridge | England | 11-Nov-1976 | 35(32) |
| 17-Jan-2012 | Jose Veiga | Macclesfield Town | Cape Verde | 18-Dec-1976 | 35(30) |
| 28-Jan-2012 | Gavin Mahon | Notts County | England | 02-Jan-1977 | 35(26) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).