| MD | Players | Clubs | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 28-Mar-2009 |  Russell Latapy | Trinidad and Tobago | Trinidad and Tobago | 02-Aug-1968 | 40(238) |
| 12-Aug-2009 | Dwight Yorke | Trinidad and Tobago | Trinidad and Tobago | 03-Nov-1971 | 37(283) |
| 09-Sep-2009 | Clayton Ince | Trinidad and Tobago | Trinidad and Tobago | 13-Jul-1972 | 37(58) |
| 14-Oct-2009 |  Cuauhtemoc Blanco | Mexico | Mexico | 17-Jan-1973 | 36(270) |
| 14-Oct-2009 | Juan Francisco Palencia | Mexico | Mexico | 28-Apr-1973 | 36(169) |
| 10-Jun-2009 | Oscar Perez | Mexico | Mexico | 01-Feb-1973 | 36(129) |
| 14-Oct-2009 |  Carlos Pavon | Honduras | Honduras | 09-Oct-1973 | 36(5) |
| 14-Oct-2009 | Trent Noel | Trinidad and Tobago | Trinidad and Tobago | 14-Jan-1974 | 35(274) |
| 12-Aug-2009 |  Andy Herron | Costa Rica | Costa Rica | 02-Feb-1974 | 35(192) |
| 09-Sep-2009 | Ricardo Gonzalez | Costa Rica | Costa Rica | 06-Mar-1974 | 35(188) |
| 12-Aug-2009 | Freddy Fernandez | Costa Rica | Costa Rica | 25-Feb-1974 | 35(169) |
| 11-Feb-2009 | Oswaldo Sanchez | Mexico | Mexico | 21-Sep-1973 | 35(144) |
| 14-Oct-2009 | Dennis Lawrence | Trinidad and Tobago | Trinidad and Tobago | 01-Aug-1974 | 35(75) |
| 14-Oct-2009 | Luis Marin | Costa Rica | Costa Rica | 10-Aug-1974 | 35(66) |
| 14-Oct-2009 | Walter Centeno | Costa Rica | Costa Rica | 06-Oct-1974 | 35(9) |
| 01-Apr-2009 |  Frankie Hejduk | United States | United States | 05-Aug-1974 | 34(240) |
| 06-Jun-2009 | Mario Beata | Honduras | Honduras | 17-Oct-1974 | 34(233) |
| 28-Mar-2009 | Samuel Caballero | Honduras | Honduras | 24-Dec-1974 | 34(95) |
| 06-Jun-2009 | Avery John | Trinidad and Tobago | Trinidad and Tobago | 18-Jun-1975 | 33(354) |
| 12-Aug-2009 | Harold Wallace | Costa Rica | Costa Rica | 04-Sep-1975 | 33(343) |
| 05-Sep-2009 | Marvin Andrews | Trinidad and Tobago | Trinidad and Tobago | 22-Dec-1975 | 33(258) |
| 05-Sep-2009 | Lyndon Andrews | Trinidad and Tobago | Trinidad and Tobago | 20-Jan-1976 | 33(229) |
| 11-Feb-2009 | Mario Rodriguez | Honduras | Honduras | 31-Jul-1975 | 33(196) |
| 14-Oct-2009 | Amado Guevara | Honduras | Honduras | 02-May-1976 | 33(165) |
| 14-Oct-2009 | William Reyes | El Salvador | El Salvador | 30-Oct-1976 | 32(349) |
| 10-Oct-2009 | Guillermo Franco | Mexico | Mexico | 03-Nov-1976 | 32(341) |
| 06-Jun-2009 | Pavel Pardo | Mexico | Mexico | 26-Jul-1976 | 32(315) |
| 06-Jun-2009 | Pablo Mastroeni | United States | United States | 29-Aug-1976 | 32(281) |
| 11-Feb-2009 | Zinha | Mexico | Mexico | 23-May-1976 | 32(264) |
| 10-Jun-2009 | William Torres | El Salvador | El Salvador | 27-Oct-1976 | 32(226) |
| 14-Oct-2009 | Noel Valladares | Honduras | Honduras | 03-May-1977 | 32(164) |
| 01-Apr-2009 | Stern John | Trinidad and Tobago | Trinidad and Tobago | 30-Oct-1976 | 32(153) |
| 09-Sep-2009 | William Sunsing | Costa Rica | Costa Rica | 12-May-1977 | 32(120) |
| 14-Oct-2009 | Douglas Sequeira | Costa Rica | Costa Rica | 23-Aug-1977 | 32(52) |
| 10-Sep-2008 | Cyd Gray | Trinidad and Tobago | Trinidad and Tobago | 21-Nov-1976 | 31(294) |
| 09-Sep-2009 | Froylan Ledezma | Costa Rica | Costa Rica | 02-Jan-1978 | 31(250) |
| 01-Apr-2009 | Leondro Augusto | Mexico | Mexico | 18-Aug-1977 | 31(226) |
| 14-Oct-2009 | Danilo Turcios | Honduras | Honduras | 08-May-1978 | 31(160) |
| 05-Sep-2009 | Carlos Hernandez | Costa Rica | Costa Rica | 07-Apr-1978 | 31(152) |
| 09-Sep-2009 | Brian Ching | United States | United States | 24-May-1978 | 31(109) |
| 01-Apr-2009 | Keyeno Thomas | Trinidad and Tobago | Trinidad and Tobago | 29-Dec-1977 | 31(94) |
| 11-Feb-2009 | Ivan Guerrero | Honduras | Honduras | 30-Nov-1977 | 31(73) |
| 09-Sep-2009 | Cristian Oviedo | Costa Rica | Costa Rica | 25-Aug-1978 | 31(15) |
| 14-Oct-2009 | Carlos Edwards | Trinidad and Tobago | Trinidad and Tobago | 24-Oct-1978 | 30(356) |
| 11-Feb-2009 | Carlos Ochoa | Mexico | Mexico | 05-Mar-1978 | 30(344) |
| 14-Oct-2009 | Mauricio Sabillon | Honduras | Honduras | 11-Nov-1978 | 30(338) |
| 10-Oct-2009 | Rafael Marquez (Mex) | Mexico | Mexico | 13-Feb-1979 | 30(240) |
| 14-Oct-2009 | Steve Cherundolo | United States | United States | 19-Feb-1979 | 30(238) |
| 14-Oct-2009 | Tim Howard | United States | United States | 06-Mar-1979 | 30(223) |
| 09-Sep-2009 | Jason Scotland | Trinidad and Tobago | Trinidad and Tobago | 18-Feb-1979 | 30(204) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).