| MD | Players | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 22-May-2011 | Brad Friedel | United States | 18-May-1971 | 40(4) |
| 16-May-2015 | Shay Given | Republic of Ireland | 20-Apr-1976 | 39(26) |
| 06-Apr-2002 | Peter Schmeichel | Denmark | 18-Nov-1963 | 38(140) |
| 26-Jul-2020 | Pepe Reina | Spain | 31-Aug-1982 | 37(330) |
| 20-May-2023 | Ashley Young | England | 09-Jul-1985 | 37(315) |
| 30-Apr-2011 | Robert Pires | France | 29-Oct-1973 | 37(183) |
| 23-Dec-1995 | Nigel Spink | England | 08-Aug-1958 | 37(137) |
| 27-Apr-1996 | Paul McGrath | Republic of Ireland | 04-Dec-1959 | 36(145) |
| 11-Dec-1993 | Gordon Cowans | England | 27-Oct-1958 | 35(46) |
| 24-Mar-1993 | Cyrille Regis | England | 09-Feb-1958 | 35(44) |
| 15-May-2004 | Dion Dublin | England | 22-Apr-1969 | 35(24) |
| 05-Feb-2000 | Colin Calderwood | Scotland | 20-Jan-1965 | 35(16) |
| 11-May-2003 | Ian Taylor | England | 04-Jun-1968 | 34(341) |
| 08-May-2004 | Ronny Johnsen | Norway | 10-Jun-1969 | 34(333) |
| 01-Dec-2001 | David Ginola | France | 25-Jan-1967 | 34(311) |
| 27-Apr-2008 | Patrik Berger | Czech Republic | 10-Nov-1973 | 34(169) |
| 13-May-2012 | Emile Heskey | England | 11-Jan-1978 | 34(123) |
| 03-May-2003 | Steve Staunton | Republic of Ireland | 19-Jan-1969 | 34(104) |
| 03-Apr-2024 | Robin Olsen | Sweden | 08-Jan-1990 | 34(86) |
| 27-Aug-1997 | Andy Townsend | Republic of Ireland | 23-Jul-1963 | 34(36) |
| 17-Mar-2002 | Paul Merson | England | 20-Mar-1968 | 33(362) |
| 23-Dec-2006 | Chris Sutton | England | 10-Mar-1973 | 33(288) |
| 15-May-2016 | Joleon Lescott | England | 16-Aug-1982 | 33(273) |
| 01-Jan-2020 | Tom Heaton | England | 15-Apr-1986 | 33(261) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).