| MD | Players | Clubs | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26-Apr-2008 | Teddy Sheringham | Colchester United | England | 02-Apr-1966 | 42(25) |
| 28-Apr-2012 | David James | Bristol City | England | 01-Aug-1970 | 41(271) |
| 02-Jan-2017 | Jussi Jaaskelainen | Wigan Athletic | Finland | 19-Apr-1975 | 41(259) |
| 05-Nov-2011 | Neil Sullivan | Doncaster Rovers | Scotland | 24-Feb-1970 | 41(254) |
| 14-Sep-2013 | Mike Pollitt | Barnsley | England | 29-Feb-1972 | 41(198) |
| 18-Sep-2012 | Maik Taylor | Millwall | Northern Ireland | 04-Sep-1971 | 41(15) |
| 03-May-2014 | Kevin Phillips | Leicester City | England | 25-Jul-1973 | 40(282) |
| 08-May-2023 | Philip Jagielka | Stoke City | England | 17-Aug-1982 | 40(264) |
| 27-Mar-2010 | Chris Powell | Leicester City | England | 08-Sep-1969 | 40(200) |
| 07-May-2011 | Graham Alexander | Burnley | Scotland | 10-Oct-1971 | 39(210) |
| 27-Oct-2007 | Aidan Davison | Colchester United | Northern Ireland | 11-May-1968 | 39(169) |
| 06-May-2018 | Paul Robinson | Birmingham City | England | 14-Dec-1978 | 39(144) |
| 28-Dec-2009 | Dean Kiely | West Bromwich Albion | Republic of Ireland | 10-Oct-1970 | 39(80) |
| 25-Nov-2008 | Gary Speed | Sheffield United | Wales | 08-Sep-1969 | 39(79) |
| 04-May-2008 | Dean Windass | Hull City | England | 01-Apr-1969 | 39(34) |
| 04-May-2008 | Dion Dublin | Norwich City | England | 22-Apr-1969 | 39(13) |
| 21-Apr-2021 | Adebayo Akinfenwa | Wycombe Wanderers | England | 10-May-1982 | 38(347) |
| 29-Dec-2019 | Gareth Barry | West Bromwich Albion | England | 23-Feb-1981 | 38(309) |
| 02-Jan-2012 | Mauricio Taricco | Brighton & Hove Albion | Argentina | 10-Mar-1973 | 38(298) |
| 13-Dec-2014 | Gabor Kiraly | Fulham | Hungary | 01-Apr-1976 | 38(256) |
| 06-May-2018 | Aaron Wilbraham | Bolton Wanderers | England | 21-Oct-1979 | 38(198) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).