| MD | Players | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15-Dec-2021 | Willy Caballero | Argentina | 28-Sep-1981 | 40(78) |
| 17-Oct-2015 | Kelvin Davis | England | 29-Sep-1976 | 39(18) |
| 08-Apr-1996 | Bruce Grobbelaar | Zimbabwe | 06-Oct-1957 | 38(185) |
| 29-Nov-1993 | Glenn Cockerill | England | 25-Aug-1955 | 38(97) |
| 29-Dec-1996 | Dave Beasant | England | 20-Mar-1959 | 37(285) |
| 27-Dec-1993 | Peter Reid | England | 20-Jun-1956 | 37(190) |
| 30-Nov-1996 | Chris Woods | England | 14-Nov-1959 | 37(17) |
| 15-May-2005 | Graeme Le Saux | England | 17-Oct-1968 | 36(210) |
| 01-Nov-2003 | Paul Jones | Wales | 18-Apr-1967 | 36(197) |
| 11-Mar-2000 | Mark Hughes | Wales | 01-Nov-1963 | 36(131) |
| 23-Apr-1994 | Kevin Moore | England | 29-Apr-1958 | 35(360) |
| 10-May-1998 | Kevin Richardson | England | 04-Dec-1962 | 35(158) |
| 22-May-2022 | Shane Long | Republic of Ireland | 22-Jan-1987 | 35(121) |
| 08-Dec-1993 | Terry Hurlock | England | 22-Sep-1958 | 35(78) |
| 04-Dec-2004 | Kasey Keller | United States | 19-Nov-1969 | 35(16) |
| 26-Dec-2003 | Chris Marsden | England | 03-Jan-1969 | 34(357) |
| 16-May-1999 | Ken Monkou | Netherlands | 29-Nov-1964 | 34(168) |
| 26-Feb-2000 | Patrick Colleter | France | 06-Nov-1965 | 34(112) |
| 14-Sep-2002 | Tahar El Khalej | Morocco | 16-Jun-1968 | 34(90) |
| 11-May-2014 | Artur Boruc | Poland | 20-Feb-1980 | 34(81) |
| 28-May-2023 | Theo Walcott | England | 16-Mar-1989 | 34(73) |
| 07-May-2022 | Fraser Forster | England | 17-Mar-1988 | 34(51) |
| 18-Dec-2004 | Jason Dodd | England | 02-Nov-1970 | 34(47) |
| 01-Feb-2003 | Francis Benali | England | 30-Dec-1968 | 34(33) |
| 24-Oct-2001 | Stuart Ripley | England | 20-Nov-1967 | 33(339) |
| 05-Dec-2018 | Steven Davis | Northern Ireland | 01-Jan-1985 | 33(338) |
| 01-Jan-2001 | Trond-Egil Soltvedt | Norway | 15-Feb-1967 | 33(321) |
| 27-Oct-2001 | Dan Petrescu | Romania | 22-Dec-1967 | 33(310) |
| 11-Sep-2002 | Andrei Kanchelskis | Russia | 23-Jan-1969 | 33(231) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).